Mattress topper or new mattress?

The quest for a good night’s sleep often prompts the same question – should you buy a mattress topper or take the plunge and purchase a brand-new mattress?

The answer depends on various factors, including budget, specific sleep discomforts, and the overall condition of your current mattress. In this article, we’ll navigate through the pros and cons of both options to help you make a more informed choice.

What is a mattress topper

A mattress topper functions as an additional cushioning layer, placed on top of the mattress to improve its pressure-relieving properties. Available in a range of different materials, such as Memory Foam, Gel Foam, or even Cool Memory Foam, toppers aim to provide an extra layer of softness and pressure relief, addressing specific needs or preferences that may not be fully met by the underlying mattress alone.

Benefits of a Mattress Topper

In the right circumstances, mattress toppers can be a fantastic way to upgrade your existing mattress. These handy additions offer a cost-effective way to improve the amount of pressure relief offered and extend the lifespan of your existing mattress.

  • Enhanced pressure relief
  • Increase the amount of softness
  • Can help to extend the lifespan of your mattress
  • A plush topper provides targeted relief for pressure points and is often considered a game-changer in transforming your sleep environment.

Scenarios Where a Mattress Topper Can Help

If your mattress is still in good shape offering plenty of support, but lacks the desired level of pressure relief and softness, a topper may offer a quick fix. It’s an ideal solution for those on a budget or looking for a temporary upgrade. Additionally, if your discomfort is limited to specific areas, such as pressure points, a topper may provide targeted relief in those areas.

Limitations of a Mattress Topper

It’s crucial to recognise that mattress toppers cannot enhance or increase the amount of underlying support provided by your existing mattress.

While toppers excel in surface-level comfort enhancements, they lack the power to remedy structural issues in the underlying mattress. If your current bed is already falling short in terms of support, investing in a mattress topper may amount to throwing good money after bad money.

When Not to Buy a Mattress Topper

If you’re regularly waking up with backaches and pains, it’s crucial to first assess the root cause before considering a mattress topper as a quick fix.

If your issues are the result of your mattress not providing enough support, introducing a soft top layer could only exacerbate the issue further. In such instances, a mattress topper may only deepen your discomfort, leaving you with aching muscles and a lighter wallet! Moreover, if you want a completely different feel or firmness level, a topper might not deliver the transformative experience you crave.

As a result, it’s important to recognise when the underlying problem demands a more substantial remedy, such as the purchase of a new mattress.

When It’s Time to Replace the Mattress

Despite the allure of mattress toppers, there comes a point in every mattress’s life when the time comes to bid farewell. Signs of wear and tear, such as sagging, an uneven surface, or a lack of support indicate your mattress has served its purpose. In such cases, investing in a new mattress becomes necessary for sustained comfort and support. A mattress, after all, is a long-term investment in your well-being, and when it reaches the end of its journey, the benefits of a fresh start become undeniable.

Benefits Of a New Mattress

Whilst mattress toppers may offer a temporary remedy, the ultimate solution lies in a new mattress. Opting for a fresh new mattress ensures both the mattress and its support layers function harmoniously, delivering the perfect balance between support and pressure relief.

  • Enhanced support
  • Renewed structural integrity
  • Greater durability
  • Uniform comfort
  • Option to select mattress based on comfort preferences

A new mattress isn’t just a purchase; it’s an investment in your well-being, providing many nights of rejuvenating sleep. With advancements in mattress technology and an array of options catering to various preferences, the prospect of a new mattress beckons as the definitive answer to achieving the sleep sanctuary you truly deserve.

FAQ’s about mattress toppers

A mattress topper is an additional layer of padding placed on top of your mattress to enhance comfort and pressure relief. It can add softness or firmness to your bed, improve pressure relief, and help to extend the lifespan of your mattress.

Using an electric blanket with a mattress topper is not recommended. The heat generated by electric blankets can accelerate the breakdown of the topper material, potentially reducing its lifespan. It’s crucial to adhere to the manufacturer’s guidelines for both the topper and the electric blanket to ensure optimal performance and longevity of both products.

Mattress toppers may provide some relief for back pain by increasing the amount of softness and pressure relief offered by your current mattress – although it’s worth noting, this only applies in certain circumstances so proceed with caution. For a longer-term solution, it’s often more beneficial to invest in a new mattress that addresses specific back pain concerns. A mattress designed for proper spinal alignment and adequate support may offer more comprehensive and lasting benefits compared to a topper. Consider consulting with a healthcare professional for personalised advice on addressing back pain concerns.


When deciding between a mattress topper and a new mattress, the decision ultimately hinges on the state of your current mattress. While toppers offer a quick and affordable solution to certain dilemmas, a new mattress provides a more comprehensive and transformative upgrade for overall sleep quality.

Consider your budget, the condition of your current mattress, and your long-term sleep goals to make a decision that aligns with your requirements. After all, whether it’s the incremental improvements of a topper or the rejuvenating embrace of a new mattress which will help determine your decision.

1,606 reviews
Free & fast delivery
24,526+ orders dispatched

Start by selecting the shape that shows the closest match to your requirements – you’ll be able to customise this later. If you can’t find your shape or need something entirely different, get in touch and we’ll be more than happy to help.

Step 1) Select the shape you wish to customise
Basic shapes
Shaped mattresses
You’ll select which side the shape is cut later
Split mattresses
You’ll select the position of the split later